ITS ORIGINS AND DEVELOPMENT.
R. CAMPBELL THOMPSON, M.A. (Cantab.).
TO MY UNCLE
ON THE HILLSIDE, BY THE LOCHSIDE, AND ON THE
HAVE OFTTIMES SERVED ME.
The theories put forward or maintained in this book are based on a study of that intricate demonology which has gradually developed throughout the lands of Western Asia. The earliest written records of this magic are found in the cuneiform incantation tablets from Assyria; and, aided by the various steppingstones afforded by Rabbinic tradition, Syriac monkish writings, and Arabic tales, we can trace its growth and decadence through three thousand years down to
its survival in modern Oriental superstition. Furthermore, the parallels afforded by Aryan and Hamitic nations show how close the grooves are in which savage ideas run, and that the principles of magic are, broadly speaking, coincident in each separate nation, and yet, as far as we know, of independent invention. All these superstitions combine to throw light on many of the peculiar customs of the Old Testament, and help to explain the hidden reason why these customs existed.
From a study of the characteristics of the evil spirits, which the Semite believed to exist everywhere, certain deductions can be made which bear intimately on our knowledge of the origins of certain tabus and the principle of atonement. These may be briefly stated thus:
(1) All evil spirits could inflict bodily hurt on man.
(2) The relations between spirits and human beings were so close that both semi-divine and semi-demoniac offspring could be born of intermarriage between them, either of human mothers or fathers.
(3) From this belief in intermarriage with spirits arose the tabus on certain sexual functions. These (according to the present theory) indicate the advent, proximity, or presence of marriageable demons who would tolerate no meddling in their amours. Hence the tribesman, fearing their jealousy, segregated the contaminated person from the rest of the tribe for such time as he deemed expedient.
(4) It frequently happened that, in spite of the caretaken to isolate all persons or things tabu, a man mightbreak an
'unwitting ' tabu, and as a result would fall sick from the attack of a resentful spirit. The priest was then called in to exorcise the demon, which he was able to do by a transference of the demoniac influence from the body of his patient into some other object.
(5) This is the base of the atonement principle. The priest first of all inveigled or drove out the demon from the sick man into a wax figure or slaughtered kid, and he was then able to destroy it. As civilisation proceeded, the most probable theory is that the original idea of the slaughtered kid became merged in that of the ordinary sacrifice representing a common meal with the god. The carcase of the kid then played the part of a 'sin-offering' in the sense in which it is now understood, instead of being a receptacle for the demon cozened forth from the patient.
(6) Having proceeded thus far, the principle of substitution for the firstborn demands attention. This apparently takes its origin in primitive cannibal feasts, the horror of which was softened as the Semites advanced in progress. With their migration perhaps to a more fertile land where stress of poverty and famine did not demand such extremities as cannibalism, and also from a contemporaneous rise in civilisation, it became natural to substitute a beast for a tribesman at the tribal sacrificial feasts.
The study of tabu from the Assyrian side has been comparatively neglected, and yet the evidence hitherto gleaned from the cuneiform writings shows that it existed in practically the same forms in Mesopotamia as in other countries. I had hoped to find more proof of its presence in certain cuneiform tablets dealing with medical and kindred subjects in the British Museum, but my two applications for permission to copy unpublished tablets of this nature were refused by the
Museum authorities. Hence the material at hand for a study of a most interesting branch of Comparative Religion is more imperfect than I could have wished, and the relative scientific value of what we actually know on this subject is proportionate to the amount of evidence which may be afforded at some later date by these privy documents.
It is almost unnecessary to say how much I am indebted to Robertson Smith's Religion of the Semites and Frazer's Golden Bough for the many quotations bearing on this subject which I have taken from them; to the Encyclopaedia Biblica and Jewish Encyclopcedia ; to that storehouse of Arabic folklore, Doughty's Arabia Deserta; to Curtiss' Primitive Semitic Religion; to Skeat's Malay Magic; and to King's various works on Assyrian religion.
To my uncle, Frederic Thompson, I owe hearty thanks, not only for the care and trouble which he has taken in reading the proof - sheets, but also for many appropriate suggestions of which I have gladly availed myself.
Such a book as this must necessarily be imperfect, and not everyone will agree with the deductions that have been made. But, as Hume says in his discussion on Miracles, "a wise man, therefore, proportions his belief to the evidence ... he weighs the opposite experiments: he considers which side is supported by the greater number of experiments: to that side he inclines with doubt and hesitation; and when at last he fixes his judgment, the evidence exceeds not what
we properly call probability."
R. Campbell Thompson.
II. Demoniac Possession and Tabu 95 - 118 119 - 141
III. Sympathetic Magic 142 - 174
IV. The Atonement Sacrifice 175 - 218
V. The Redemption of the Firstborn 219 - 244
Appendix 245 - 256
Index 257 - 283
List of Biblical Quotations 285 - 286
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS.
A.J.S.L. American Journal of Semitic Languages.
A.S.K.T. Haupt, Akkadische und Sumerische Keilschrifttexte.
C.I.S. Corpus Inscriptionum Semiticarum.
C.T. Cuneiform Texts from Babylonian Tablets (British Museum
Devils Thompson, Devils and Evil Spirits of Babylonia.
G.B. Frazer, Golden Bough.
J. A. Journal Asiatique.
J.A.O.S. Journal of the American Oriental Society.
J.A.S. Journal of the Asiatic Society.
J.B.L. Journal of Biblical Literature.
J.E.S. Journal of the Ethnological Society.
J.Q. Jewish Quarterly.
K. References to Kouyunjik Tablets in the British Museum.
Maklu The Maklu Series, published by Tallqvist, Die assyrische
O.T.J.C. Robertson Smith, Old Testament in the Jewish Church.
P.E.F. Palestine Exploration Fund.
P.S.B.A. Proceedings of the Society of Biblical Archaeology.
S. References to Tablets in the British Museum found by
Surpu The Surpu Series, published by Zimmern, Die Beschwb'rungstafeln
T.S.B. A. Transactions of the Society of Biblical Archaeology.
W.A.I. Rawlinson, Inscriptions of Western Asia.
Tt.K. Zeitschrift fur Assyriologie.
Z.D.M.G. Zeitschrift der Deutschen Morgenlandischen Gesellschaft.